How the federal IDR process actually resolves.
Aggregated from the public CMS Federal IDR Public Use Files for 2025 Q3 and 2025 Q4 — 3,007,933 dispute line items. Public government data, presented for market context.
Source & independence. Figures on this page are derived from the CMS Federal IDR Public Use Files published under the No Surprises Act. The underlying data is public and was produced by the U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). This is public government data presented for educational and market-context purposes. It reflects determinations made across the federal IDR process by certified IDR entities — not determinations made by Vanta. Vanta Health Group is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or acting on behalf of CMS.
Outcomes, offers, and the spread across IDR entities.
Sort any column. Win rate is the share of decided line items that favored the provider/facility. “% of QPA” is the prevailing offer relative to the qualifying payment amount.
Who prevails
Share of decided determinations, 2025 Q3 + 2025 Q4.
Prevailing offer vs. QPA
Winning offer as a share of the qualifying payment amount (line items).
Reviewer variance · the "panel drifts" problem, in the data
Across the 15 highest-volume certified IDR entities, the provider win rate ranges from 54.9% (ProPeer Resources, LLC) to 96.1% (Island Peer Review Organization) — a 41-point spread on the same federal process. Turnaround runs from 30.2 days (Maximus Federal Services, Inc.) to 98.6 days (Medical Evaluators of Texas).
Public federal data — not Vanta determinations. Sort the table below to see it yourself.
| Category | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Federal Hearings and Appeals Services, Inc. | 900,778 | 81.4% | 37.2 | $512 |
| C2C Innovative Solutions, Inc. | 378,154 | 89.2% | 56.6 | $666 |
| Provider Resources, Inc. | 278,568 | 95.1% | 55.2 | $564 |
| Island Peer Review Organization | 277,936 | 96.1% | 53.3 | $933 |
| MCMC Services, LLC | 192,734 | 91.4% | 51.7 | $529 |
| EdiPhy Advisors, L.L.C. | 178,618 | 90.4% | 41.3 | $997 |
| Maximus Federal Services, Inc. | 154,986 | 90.7% | 30.2 | $617 |
| Network Medical Review Company, Ltd. | 144,346 | 69.8% | 63.2 | $574 |
| iMPROve Health | 140,588 | 86% | 88.8 | $570 |
| National Medical Reviews, Inc. | 117,672 | 71.3% | 41.6 | $402 |
| Medical Evaluators of Texas | 82,964 | 55.8% | 98.6 | $532 |
| Keystone Peer Review Organization, Inc. | 64,527 | 80.2% | 31.6 | $511 |
| ProPeer Resources, LLC | 57,399 | 54.9% | 31.7 | $684 |
| Capitol Bridge, LLC | 19,733 | 63% | 31.4 | $693 |
| Livanta (DBA:Commence) | 18,930 | 62.5% | 31.2 | $900 |
Showing 15 of 15 rows. Click a column to sort.
Use of the CMS Federal IDR Public Use Files is subject to the CMS data disclaimer and user agreement. CMS data disclaimer & user agreement. Source: CMS Federal IDR reports. Data generated 2026-11-19.
Notes: figures are line-item level and cover determinations in the selected quarters only. Averages are simple means and can be pulled by outliers; batched disputes are counted per line item. “Provider win” reflects the party in whose favor the payment determination was made, not the dollar amount. This page reflects determinations made across the federal IDR process by certified IDR entities — not determinations made by Vanta.